Aries The First to die

Taurus The one who comes home at the end to find everyone dead

Gemini The one who figures out who/what the killer is

Cancer The one who says "Hello? Who's there?" as if the killer will answer

Leo The one who tries to fight back and ends up dead

Virgo The one who sacrifices themselves

Libra The one who says "everybody stay calm!" then freaks out themselves

Scorpio The one who runs out the front door instead of upstairs

Sagittarius The one who is secretly helping the killer

Capricorn The one who snapped and went on a killing spree

Aquarius The one who makes it until the end

Pisces The one who screams at everything